PHIL 3160 – Philosophy of Happiness

What is it, how can we best pursue it, why should we? Supporting the study of these and related questions at Middle Tennessee State University and beyond. "Examining the concept of human happiness and its application in everyday living as discussed since antiquity by philosophers, psychologists, writers, spiritual leaders, and contributors to pop culture."

Up@dawn 2.0

Monday, February 14, 2022

Chapter 2 Haybron's short intro

I particularly like this chapter. Daniel Haybron's opens up with an excerpt from Ron Haybron's, "Island;" the way he describes the sun going down on the pond and the birds upon the water; and the water in the sand, helps to place you in his shoes and feel like you're there. And when he talks about the veil between us and the truth of existence being very thin, I guess his referring to us as humankind, they're not being much difference between us and I assume the truth of existence being that feeling of being so small in the grand scheme of things. I can relate and being in a similar scene in nature, where your mind as he describes the is free of other interruptions. Although he describes it as a mindless existence and normally we think of mindfulness in terms of meditation; the author also describe this as being "meditative, with no need of mantras or quiet rooms." I can relate to having this feeling not only on the open water, but also in some other settings, also.


I also really liked this chapter because Hebron goes on to describe a happy man that he calls Big Joe and he too uses descriptive writing to make you feel like you're in the setting- with Big Joe catching dolphin in the ocean, reeling in fish; and even admiring them for their beauty although on the hunts to capture them, to eat. And even makes you feel the danger associated with his mission. He describes Joe and his wife's life of needing little resources to live on, building his own home, and doing all of his own maintenance, only a carpentry job in addition to the fishing that he does, keeping the bills paid. Sounds like a very confident man, get mild tempered; and independent- enjoying very much so being his own boss. Haybron used the example of Joe, to show how as society, we judge someone's happiness (sometimes,) by observing the person to assess their emotional condition. However Hebron goes on to say that emotional condition is much deeper than just a person's body language etc. 


In this chapter he focuses on the emotional state theory of happiness. And says that considering this date to be happy is to have a favorable emotional condition. However he basically says you can't just go off of outward appearances of happiness such as smiling etc because there's more to it than just being happy you have to actually feel happy. He says most people list days such as the birth of their child etc as the happiest days of their lives; however, basically says that you can't just factor that one day into being happy; and describes sustained periods of happiness more in relation to a person actually being happy and then just having one extremely happy day because of extremely happy event. 


Then he goes on to describe the three aspects that are important and happiness, in relation to the emotional state theory. The first is endorsement which is feeling happy and other classic emotions, the second is engagement through vitality and flow which is basically finding interest in your own life/ not being depressed, or uninterested in the things in it. And the third being attunements which is a piece of mind, confidence, expensiveness... And for this he gives the example of tranquility. He describes this state of attunement as when a person relaxes blossoms and living seems to be natural without inhibition." And further describes it as when you feel safe secure and unthreatened. Attainment has three basic aspects that he lists as inner calmness (or tranquility,) confidence, and expansiveness of mood or spirit (or being carefree or uncompressed.) He goes on to say that confidence he means here as a somatic confidence (of feeling wholy at home in your body,) rather than the egotistical assumption of the word confidence. And describes stress sort of as something that can smolder ones ability for their happiness to burn brightly, if you will. 

Then the author introduces us to another fictional character by the name of Robert who outwardly appears to be very happy but whom he says breaks down in tears before falling asleep each night. Hedonicly speaking Robert would be considered as happy however psychologically speaking he is obviously depressed to be crying every night, and therefore can't be technically happy. Haybron says that there are non-conscious aspects of our emotional conditions as well.  And those non-conscious aspects he says our defense within our happiness. He describes the person's mood propensity as they're likelihood to experience certain moods and emotions over others and temperament he says is more fixated around somebody's mood propensity which he says changes with circumstances.


Here Haybron sums up the chapter by saying that looking at happiness as emotional well-being would have two parts which consist of your emotions and your moods in addition to your mood propensity and so he says that to be happy and for once emotional condition to be favorable as a whole not only do their emotions and mood matter but also their propensity to them, which he contributes to circumstances. As opposed to hedonism, which just looks at the experiences that you're given rather than your emotions to them. He then quotes a colleague and Buddhist thinker who describes a similar view as his when he says "by happiness I mean here a deep sense of flourishing that arises from an exceptionally healthy mind." And then he leads into the next chapter in which he will cover the third theory the life satisfaction theory.


Sunday, February 13, 2022

Chapter one of Haybron's happiness a very short introduction

 In chapter 1 Haybron quotes Crito to Socrates, who awaited execution. I think this really depicts the extremely mindful person that Socrates was. Crito seems to be saying that he always knew that Socrates was highly filled with mindfulness; but that he can't believe that even in, what would be an extremely terrifying experience to anyone else, that Socrates maintains that unaltered state of mindfulness (even when awaiting his own death. ) 


Quotes Daniel Everett who had studied the Pirahas lifestyle, and what makes their society such a happy place to live; as they live in the Amazon, without the materialistic things that we are accustomed to in our society, but when studied by psychologist have appeared to be some of the happiest people ever. Everett had written that he had once asked the Pariaha's if they knew why he was there; and judging from their responses it seems that they were oblivious to why someone would want to study them or that somebody was. It seems that they assumed that he felt the same way that they did, that it was just wonderful place to be.


 At the end of the chapter, Haybron begins to outline the same different outlooks on happiness, as he had described in his encyclopedia entry; and then throws in a little humor by telling the readers that if they're just interested and finding out quickly the meaning of happiness they don't have to proceed through the whole book, for they could simply just read chapters 1, 2, 5 and 8. Lol. 

Thoughts on Haybron's Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy Entry

 Well, of course this text is only centered around the psychological consideration for happiness and not happiness in the sense of the value term; but I would have to agree; however, with the fact that happiness cannot simply be equal or the same as well-being because there are other factors (that one would have to take into account,) that when summed up, equate to well-being, for each individual, as a whole.


That being said, and looking at happiness in terms of a psychological description, I do see why happiness; even narrowing it down to a psychological state, becomes such a topic of debate. 

Considering the two aspects to be considered within the psychological theories, surrounding the term and meaning, of the word happiness: state of mind and a life gone well; I feel as though happiness could actually be a combination of the two. 


Although I do not agree with the first case, in which, psychologically speaking, some believe that happiness is not valuable at all. I would have to agree with the second case, which gives prudential value to happiness.

But at the same time, like I said, I do not think that happiness is equal to well-being; nor that they are in essence, in or of the same thing.

However I do lean strongly towards the individuality factor, within the article, which discusses how we consider that what benefits one person, may not benefit another; or what one person desires, may not be desirable, to another.

I feel like this is because what each of us values within our lives are different, because we are all different; and even if two people were to say value the same things, they are still individuals; and they may value those same things, but at different degrees. The saying that comes to mind, when considering this factor, for me is: "what's good for the goose, is not always good for the gander." I feel like two individuals, could even have the similar morals and ethics (in terms of virtues they posses;) and possibly even the same religious (or non-religious outlooks on life;) yet could still value similar attributes to their happiness at differing degrees. 

I also feel like the topic of how we feel towards other people's success and happiness or misfortune, to me at least, seems like a tricky area of discussion. It is also subjective to individuality, in my mind. Because while I would have sympathy for someone who was doing poorly, there are always some individuals; regardless of the reason, that will rejoice actually in the misfortune of someone else. And while we should rejoice in the good fortunes of others, as the text does state, there are those who envy when someone else is doing well.

While often, I would agree with the aristotleans, that a life will lived- a life full of virtuous activity, in which one fills their human capacity to the fullest extent; should be most desirable, I also feel that one cannot an honesty say that one is truly happy, without ever fully receiving anything outside of those virtues, that attributed to their happiness; other than the happiness they received by just doing what was right, throughout the course of a life.

While I agree to some extent that a happy life could be a balance of pleasant and unpleasant experiences, to some extent; I would have to lean more towards the life satisfaction theory, which gives an affirmation of the happiness one feels about one's life as a whole; and also feel some agreement towards the emotional state view with the different categories that make up once happiness. I think again for me the term that comes to mind is individuality- we all come from different heredity, different social backgrounds; and what makes each of us unique, and even makes each of us have perhaps a differing set of virtues or moral standards, and of course what makes each of us happy, will always be different, and unique, just as we are.

I for one feel that the Gallup world pole study on life satisfaction is an inaccurate account, of the relationship between material and prosperity and life satisfaction. I feel that happiness is a very big component of life satisfaction; and I do not feel that happiness comes in material form. 

As an individual I have always found perspective to be a very interesting topic. As it relates to this reading, one onlooker could see someone with a high household income, and luxury conveniences; as someone who has everything together, and could mistakenly assume that that person is happy. Meanwhile they could feel sorrow for a family let's say that is struggling through homelessness; however, not realizing that the true calculation of the homeless family's happiness, is in actuality, quite higher than that of the family who is better off in terms of material value. Especially over the past couple of years with the pandemic, and the astronomical number of families suffering through homelessness; and if one were to watch some of the advertisements of companies like rocket mortgage, which released videos, to broadcast the severity of the problem of homelessness in our nation right now; I would think that even more so than ever, it would be obvious that the calculations of people reporting to be happy even in homelessness, would be even higher than usual.

For me I even feel that some things that make us feel happy, can also create additional talents, etc; and in essence create additional happiness in us; and also can create additional happiness in which we want to share with others, through those talents. I guess what I'm saying is that I believe there are different tiers of happiness; someone could be happy in their relationship for instance, and it could make them so happy that they find talents within them, that they feel like they could share with the world; and from sharing those talents with the world they couldn't essence create additional happiness in other people.

At any rate, I definitely see why happiness is such a hot topic of debate amongst philosophers. I for one do believe in God, and a heaven; however, much like my views on happiness, I feel that each individuals version of heaven, is different from anyone else's. Just as I feel that each individual's definition of happiness is different. And also, that there are different tiers and aspects that make up our happiness as a whole; and that the happiness of our lives as we see them overall can also change over time through life experiences.

"Collaborative Living"

What would Epicurus say?

They Took a Chance on Collaborative Living. They Lost Everything.
A group that sought to create Connecticut's first experiment in collaborative living fell short. Some of the investors lost their life savings.

For Claudia Ruffle, living in a co-housing community was a lifelong dream. She longed for connection with people who shared her values, particularly around concern for the environment. But as an introvert, she found it hard to meet people on her own.

Co-housing, a form of collaborative living that originated in Denmark, provided "a structure where I didn't have to be outgoing and could still get the benefit of getting to know people," said Ms. Ruffle, 72, a former substitute teacher and administrative secretary. "It compensated for my lack of outgoingness."

So she was among the early supporters of what was envisioned as Connecticut's first co-housing community. After more than a decade of planning, the project, called Rocky Corner, finally broke ground in 2018 on a 33-acre plot in Bethany, a suburb of New Haven.

Ms. Ruffle and a friend contracted to purchase one of the attached housing units there, and sold their home in New Haven in anticipation of closing in 2019. But their closing date kept getting extended. And then members of the community were told that the project was having a cash flow problem... nyt

Friday, February 4, 2022

This made me smile this morning! I hope all have a great weekend!!!

Tuesday, January 18, 2022

Public philosophy

Since the millennium, there has been a huge increase in the visibility of philosophy, both online and off. There are, of course, books on philosophy, but also numerous popular live events, courses, podcasts, television and radio programmes, and newspaper columns. Philosophy today is as likely to be found on YouTube as it is in a bookshop or library. Just to mention a few examples of freely accessible online public philosophy initiatives: Michael Sandel's 'Justice' course, the BBC's History of Ideas animations, or the many popular philosophy podcasts, including History of Philosophy Without Any Gaps from Peter Adamson, Philosophy Bites from David Edmonds and Nigel Warburton, and the philosophy episodes of the BBC Radio 4 series In Our Time. This complex and heterogeneous phenomenon is generally called 'public philosophy'. It's philosophy done in public rather than behind the doors of seminar or lecture rooms, or in paywalled academic journals... (continues)

https://psyche.co/ideas/what-public-philosophy-is-and-why-we-need-it-more-than-ever

Monday, January 17, 2022

"Happiness"-Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

 

Happiness

First published Wed Jul 6, 2011; substantive revision Thu May 28, 2020

There are roughly two philosophical literatures on “happiness,” each corresponding to a different sense of the term. One uses ‘happiness’ as a value term, roughly synonymous with well-being or flourishing. The other body of work uses the word as a purely descriptive psychological term, akin to ‘depression’ or ‘tranquility’. An important project in the philosophy of happiness is simply getting clear on what various writers are talking about: what are the important meanings of the term and how do they connect? While the “well-being” sense of happiness receives significant attention in the contemporary literature on well-being, the psychological notion is undergoing a revival as a major focus of philosophical inquiry, following on recent developments in the science of happiness. This entry focuses on the psychological sense of happiness (for the well-being notion, see the entry on well-being). The main accounts of happiness in this sense are hedonism, the life satisfaction theory, and the emotional state theory. Leaving verbal questions behind, we find that happiness in the psychological sense has always been an important concern of philosophers. Yet the significance of happiness for a good life has been hotly disputed in recent decades. Further questions of contemporary interest concern the relation between the philosophy and science of happiness, as well as the role of happiness in social and political decision-making...(continues)

Saturday, January 8, 2022

A capacity for happiness

“Happiness comes of the capacity to feel deeply, to enjoy simply, to think freely, to risk life, to be needed.” (Margaret) Storm Jameson 

Saturday, January 1, 2022

be happy still

"Considering that, all hatred driven hence,
The soul recovers radical innocence
And learns at last that it is self-delighting,
Self-appeasing, self-affrighting,
And that its own sweet will is Heaven’s will;
She can, though every face should scowl
And every windy quarter howl
Or every bellows burst, be happy still."

Yeats, A Poem for My Daughter, stanza 9-in "Bewilderment: A Novel" by Richard Powers: https://a.co/0IrGQsH

Why Are We So Good at Feeling Bad?

… Of course, not every affliction has an evolutionary purpose. People get sick. But our extraordinary susceptibility to misery does raise ...