Successor site to the Philosophy of Happiness blog (http://philoshap.blogspot.com/) that supported PHIL 3160 at MTSU, 2011-2019. The course returns Fall 2025.
PHIL 3160 – Philosophy of Happiness
Up@dawn 2.0
Wednesday, February 23, 2022
Chapter 4 measuring happiness
I find the quote at the beginning of the chapter very intriguing, as I should, being that of Ernest Hemingway; whom stated that "happiness in intelligent people, is the rarest thing I know."
I think I know what he means by that. However, I've known some highly intelligent people; whom don't necessarily lead the type of lives that are stereotypical of what one would consider "a happy American life," yet I believe that some of those people would report as being happy, by their own standards.
Although some people, such as my parents, claim to be happy alone; they enjoy their own company, and find their own-selves to be highly entertaining. Lol.
Anyways in this chapter Haybron focuses on the problem with measuring happiness. He discusses how we tend to measure it of other people by evaluating what we see on the outside.
But then goes on to discuss how it has been discovered that happiness is more of an internal measure taken by the individual themselves.
And then further discusses how even that measure can be a skewed measure, as people doing self evaluations of their happiness, and to lean more towards the positive when reporting their own happiness.
And so, he begins to ask "are people as happy as they say they are?" He says that numbers measured in the studies and world poll on happiness, that indicates that 94% of Americans claim to be happy, are preposterous.
Haybron then provides quantitative reasoning or his opinion, by providing data from other surveys; conducted on, for instance, depression and anxiety; and loneliness and stress, within the United States. And also surveys, which were conducted on children (as well as college age young adults,) in the United States, reported having contemplated or attempted suicide, and or reported as having eating disorders.
Haybron also, discusses the 1% of Americans that are incarcerated; and the 3%, being under the supervision of the criminal Justice system; and how those figures alone discredit the possibility that only 6% of all Americans are unhappy.
He ends the chapter by saying that "people might tend to overstate their happiness for two different reasons: one being positivity biases affecting the way that we think about ourselves," and says that "we tend to have overly rosy views on ourselves and our futures, a phenomenon known as positive illusions" (which I referred to above, and he defines as "leaning towards the positive side of things.") And the second reason that he gives, being that "we lack clear standards of what it means to be happy." He basically says that not having clear definition of what it means to be happy allows people to lie about their happiness without actually lying. This is kind of like saying that without laws people are more likely to break basic moral codes of ethics, in a way. I mean without a true definition of happiness, people aren't accountable, if you will; for skewing their answers towards the positives, if they don't have a valid definition to go off of.
Tuesday, February 22, 2022
These 12 Women Don’t Want It All. They Want Better.
Feb.
22, 2022, 12:01 a.m. ET
Ms.
Wildman is a staff editor and writer in Opinion.
What
are the choices in life that shape our happiness,
our self-worth, our sense that we’ve grown up and evolved past the model
provided by our parents? What about the ways others treat us, and the ways we
treat ourselves, that leave us feeling uncertain, exhausted, lonely? What
success do we believe we can achieve — and what success do we believe we
deserve?
For our new focus group by Times
Opinion, we decided to explore some of these ideas in our pressure-filled era,
by listening to women about the shifts they’ve seen and felt in work life,
careers, relationships, parenting and gender roles in recent years.
The members of the group, ages 22 to
43, are married and unmarried, partnered and unpartnered, mothers and avowed
never-mothers. Eleven are cis-gendered and one identified as a woman and
nonbinary. They ran the gamut in work experience and politics (six Biden
supporters, four Trump supporters, and two who were for “someone else” in
2020). Those differences aside, all of them saw gender as a defining aspect of
their lives. Several had seen men leap ahead of them at work, yet were also
deeply skeptical of movements aiming to help women like #MeToo. Mothers, they
all agreed, bore the brunt of the practicalities regarding child care, as well
as the expectations of caregiving. That, in turn, had led more than one woman
to decide parenting was not in their future.
The conversation, moderated by focus
group veteran Kristen Soltis Anderson, was frank and personal. Younger
participants were, for the most part, opting to delay or forgo parenthood and
marriage, often seeing those choices more in the framework of constraint and
burden rather than as happy life-cycle events. Many of the women were making
different decisions — and seeing their options as more expansive — than those
of their mothers.
This is the fifth group in our
series, America in Focus, which seeks to hear and understand the opinions of
wider cross-sections of Americans. This transcript has been edited for length
and clarity; an audio recording and video clips of the session are also
included.
(Continues with interviews at link above)
Monday, February 21, 2022
Working at it
https://t.co/AiLjiAVxmR
(https://twitter.com/philosophybites/status/1495789596428414983?s=02)
Yale’s Happiness Professor Says Anxiety Is Destroying Her Students
"So what’s the answer? What’s the purpose of life? It’s smelling your coffee in the morning. [Laughs.] Loving your kids. Having sex and daisies and springtime. It’s all the good things in life. That’s what it is." Don't forget to read, walk, be kind etc.https://t.co/xQvmvTWCMC
— Phil Oliver (@OSOPHER) February 21, 2022
Saturday, February 19, 2022
Morning mantra
"When you arise in the morning, think of what a precious privilege it is to be alive - to breathe, to think, to enjoy, to love… Dwell on the beauty of life. Watch the stars, and see yourself running with them." --Marcus Aurelius
Haybron's chapter 3
Haybron basically discredits the life satisfaction theory in chapter 3; and even ends the chapter by saying "I just want my kids to be happy might be a little exaggerated. But it sounds a whole lot more compelling than I just want my kids to be satisfied. If you want them to be satisfied, suggest they think of Tiny Tim and count their blessings."
This chapter really made me start to discredit the life satisfaction theory, but for different reasons than he gives; for instance, I feel as though someone could say that they are not satisfied with their life, yet also state that they are happy, despite the dissatisfaction with the overall outcome of their life. For instance someone could be dissatisfied with their life, but happy overall (from the love they feel for their children and grandchildren; and the satisfaction that they see that they have in their lives, despite lacking that satisfaction in their own.
With that being said, I would have to say what's that in order for a life to be deemed good, it should contain both life satisfaction and happiness.
Wednesday, February 16, 2022
Thoughts on Haybron's Happiness Chapter One
In the opening of chapter one the author discusses how there has never been a better time to be alive. While I agree with that opening statement I also found it to be interesting because the last several years our world has been so chaotic. Even with that I know that time period we currently live in is a much happier time than previous generations regardless of the confusion our world is facing. Like the author stated, today we enjoy material and cultural abundance that previous generations only dreamt of, but I question if those resources truly make us any happier.
Socrates was the perfect example of being happier with less. While I don't know that his way of life is the answer, I do know that overconsumption and materialism don't necessarily lead to happiness either.
I also like how the author discussed how we would be unwise to generalize large groups in humanity because of what they possess or don't possess. Like the author said there are some many levels of poverty and I think that poverty can be a frame of mind and not just a lack of possessions. In my own life for example I'd have to say there were times when I was happier when I had less than all the material possessions I currently own.
Personally, I think the meaning of happiness is every changing and like the author stated can mean many things. It's not so much about the word happiness, but about the meaning of the words you use to describe it.
SL
Monday, February 14, 2022
How Wanting Less Leads to Satisfaction
And the payoff? "I have diligently numbered the days of pure and genuine happiness which have fallen to my lot," he wrote. "They amount to 14."
As an observer, I understand the problem. I write a column about human happiness for The Atlantic and teach classes on the subject at Harvard. I know that satisfaction is one of the core "macronutrients" of happiness (the other two being enjoyment and meaning), and that its slippery nature is one of the reasons happiness is often so elusive as well...
https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2022/03/why-we-are-never-satisfied-happiness/621304/Happiness in a sense (Jennifer, MALA 22)
Posted for Jennifer... [Jennifer, Ashley, and Shira, please post directly to this site... read and comment on one another's posts]
Wednesday, February 9, 2022
Happiness in a sense
Considering the question first posed in the text, "what is happiness?", and dissecting the elucidation of the word into two subject matters: Happiness as it pertains to a state of mind, and happiness in relation to a life that goes well for the person leading it; I can begin to understand how answering the expansive question " what is happiness?," to be challenging. Considering happiness in a psychological sense, we need to take into account the various mental states that happiness can affect. For one cannot experience the state of happiness without witnessing or at least simply acknowledging the possibility it’s opposite(s). Several opposing emotions to happiness are sorrow, depression, melancholy, grief, disdain, and discontempt. If we contemplate happiness in a mental state of mind sense, we must also infer psychologically that the opposing emotions are also a state of mind. Each one, or the lack of each one, lends itself to include pleasure, satisfaction, or an overall positive emotional condition, as mentioned in the reading.
The second case of identifying happiness being “a life well spent,” leaves me wanting to explore the concept or idea of “a life well spent” in further depth. As Ashley had mentioned, it is highly probable that two individuals' perception of that life well spent will vary to some degree. I believe that variance depends a great deal on the value placed on the idea or concept of happiness and what consists of a happy state of mind, as well as a happy life.
In my field of work, I have encountered a variety of individuals whose lives by societal norms would be considered lacking in some capacity. Their hardships and current social standings would be less than ideal for the “average”, let's say American. However, their disposition on their life, being fully aware of their struggles and limitations, and lack of opportunities thus far towards this “life well spent” conceptualization, possesses a uniquely positive mindset. I would dare say they would express their state of mind to be happy, enough. Which encourages me to consider that happiness is a posture between the two subject matters presented in the text. It’s actual truth lies within a domain of reality that we as a society cannot construct simply based on a set of ideas. I believe that limits happiness to its barest minimum. I suppose my current stance would fall into the hybrid theory of happiness and that the true depth of happiness cannot be measured.
However, as a people, we have certainly tried to define and measure this idea. Material prosperity, as mentioned, appears to be one of the highest currencies for happiness. I believe another is the characteristic that a steady positive disposition equates to being happy; when in reality both of these things, material and a positive disposition, can be fabricated to any degree. That’s not saying that monitarty gain doesn’t have it’s advantages, and a positive disposition doesn’t have a place, I believe they both serve a purpose; however, I am not certain that purpose lends itself to the measure of what happiness is.
Returning to the value of happiness. Is it necessary for the overall well-being of life? I personally, don’t believe so. The idea of well-being itself, to me, encompasses mental, physical, emotional, and spiritual well being. A healthy balance of optimism as well as affliction. Typically the idea of discomfort and happiness don’t coincide with one another. I feel that each is imperative, if nothing else, unavoidable, in acquiring a well being self.
Here is where many stumble in pursuit of happiness. Our normative views exclude the notion of suffering, true suffering, in regards to a happy life. Struggle, yes. Struggle is almost this idea that is essential to the “American standard” of happiness; however, to suffer…suffering would imply happiness is lost or has been lost to some degree. Placing the value of one’s happiness at a level I am uncomfortable with. Happiness is not a state of one’s character, yet at times it seems that we value it as such. I believe to do so is a discredit to the individual and the “life they spent”, well or unwell, an impossible scale that is not equitable from one to judge.
So for now, I suppose we will continue to philosophize on the idea of happiness. Is it like beauty? It’s simply in the eye of the beholder.
Why Are We So Good at Feeling Bad?
… Of course, not every affliction has an evolutionary purpose. People get sick. But our extraordinary susceptibility to misery does raise ...
-
Let's introduce ourselves, fellow Happiness scholars/pursuers. I'm Dr. Oliver, I've been teaching this course in alternate years...
-
UPDATE, Oct. 2 . The schedule is set. For those who've not declared a topic preference, there's still time. Look in the first four c...
-
We're just a little over a week few days out from the Fall '23 semester Opening Day! Let's introduce ourselves. My brief bio is...