PHIL 3160 – Philosophy of Happiness

What is it, how can we best pursue it, why should we? Supporting the study of these and related questions at Middle Tennessee State University and beyond. "Examining the concept of human happiness and its application in everyday living as discussed since antiquity by philosophers, psychologists, writers, spiritual leaders, and contributors to pop culture."

Up@dawn 2.0

Friday, October 31, 2025

From MTSU student to Philosophy professor, Kaity Newman finds her way home – MTSU News

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. — When Kaity Newmanwalks into Room 202 of the James Union Building on the campus of Middle Tennessee State University, she can't help but smile.

Dr. Kaity Newman 

The room feels familiar. Not just because she's taught here this semester, but because it's the same classroom where she sat wide-eyed as an undergraduate student taking Introduction to Philosophy at MTSU more than a decade ago.

"Standing at the front of that room now, where I once sat as a student, it's surreal," said Newman, a new lecturer in the Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies. "It feels really good being back on campus."

https://mtsunews.com/philosophy-professor-mtsu-alumna/

Happy Halloween

https://bsky.app/profile/osopher.bsky.social/post/3m4iclswh5s24

Questions NOV 4

Commencing Burkeman's 4,000 Weeks (Intro, 1-2 (p.55)

  1. How long must you live to reach 4,000 weeks? 6,400? Does this surprise or disturb or motivate you in any way? How would you feel if you had less than 800 weeks left (to reach 4,000)?
  2. What do you think of Seneca's lament? And Nagel's observation? 4
  3. Do you wage a daily battle against online distraction? 6 Or have you surrendered?
  4. What's the "maddening truth about time"? 9
  5. Have you found your "larger cause"? 12
  6. Does time feel to you like a conveyor belt you can't keep up with? What does this analogy suggest is wrong with our relation to time? 20 Would we be wise to rethink that relation, in terms of the time it takes to actually complete specific tasks (like a "pissing whyle" for instance)? Have you had an experience of timelessness like Jung's? 22
  7. What's the Pomodoro Technique? Have you ever tried it, or anything like it? How'd that go? 27
  8. Have you conquered FOMO? Are you trying? Are you comfortable with COMO (Certainty...)? 33
  9. Does Busytown appeal to you?
  10. What was Arnold Bennett's dubious assumption? 40
  11. Have you experienced "existential overwhelm"? 45 If you believe in an afterlife, does that help?
  12. Do you send e-cards? 52 Will you still? How about letters, notes, postcards?



 

Thursday, October 30, 2025

Boo!

To[morrow] is Halloween, or All Hallows’ Eve, a day in which the dead are traditionally believed to walk among the living. Communities all across the country throw Halloween parties and parades, but Salem, Massachusetts, goes all out...trying to make everyone happy...”*

Bring candy to class, if you want. Best costume(s) get extra bases on the scorecard.

 
It started with “Haunted Happenings” in the 1980s, a celebration that took place over a single weekend. But more and more happenings were added to the events calendar every year until they filled the entire month of October and now a quarter of a million tourists flock to Salem to celebrate the monthlong Festival of the Dead. There’s a psychic fair and witchcraft expo every day. Psychic mediums deliver messages from departed loved ones — or an expert can teach you how to communicate with the dead on your own. Witch doctors and hoodoo practitioners explain the art of graveyard conjuring. There are sรฉances and cemetery tours. You can solemnly honor your lost loved ones at the Dumb Supper, a feast with the dead. And the whole thing culminates with The Official Salem Witches’ Halloween Ball at the historic Hawthorne Hotel.

Salem has had a complicated relationship with witches ever since the infamous witch trials of 1692. Over the course of a year nearly 200 residents of Essex County were falsely accused of witchcraft; 19 people were hanged and one man was tortured to death. For generations after the trials the residents of Salem Town and Salem Village just wanted to put the tragedy behind them — so much so that Salem Village changed its name to Danvers. But some modern-day pagans and Wicca practitioners have turned Salem into a pilgrimage site so the city ironically, and somewhat uneasily, has made witchcraft part of its marketing strategy. Author J.W. Ocker wrote about this phenomenon in A Season with the Witch: The Magic and Mayhem of Halloween in Salem, Massachusetts (2016). He says:

“The Witches, capital W, religious Witches, they balk a little bit at the Halloween witch, because it’s ugly and it’s a stereotype, and it has all these historical associations with it. Then there are people like the historians who balk at the religious witches, who kind of co-opt the cause of the accused witches by saying that they were almost martyrs for the cause. Then there’s the city trying to make everyone happy.” WA

Wednesday, October 29, 2025

๐Ÿ• party


We'll plan to dismiss class a little early, so any who want to attend can get over to the JUB before the pizza (and the people) get gone.
---
FYI, my Spring '26 upper division course:

MALA (Master of Liberal Arts) 6050-

Philosophy in Recent American Fiction

Meeting Tuesdays at 6 pm, James Union Building 202

We'll all read three recent (=21st century) novels together – Richard Ford’s Be Mine, Richard
Powers’s Playground, and Rebecca Newberger Goldstein’s 36 Arguments for the Existence of
God: A Work of Fiction – and each of us will additionally read and report on either a fourth novel
of your choice, or on a specific author’s life and works.*

*Some possible fourth choices (to name just a few), for individual reports:
The Candy House by Jennifer Egan (2022) - Explores themes of memory, connection, and
digital surveillance. Creation Lake by Rachel Kushner (2024) - Considers whether the path to
emancipation from what ails modern life is not revolt, but a return to the ancient past. Demon
Copperhead by Barbara Kingsolver (2024) - a new take on Dickens's Copperfield. Flight
Behavior by Kingsolver (2012) - Explores climate change, ecological disruption, and
human responsibility. Any of the other Frank Bascombe novels by Richard Ford. Any other
Richard Powers novels. Any other Rebecca Goldstein novels…

For more information:
● phil.oliver@mtsu.edu
● https://prafmtsu.blogspot.com/

A.I. Threatens Our Ability to Understand the World

Artificial intelligence threatens students' most basic skills. If they lose their ability to understand what they read, will they lose their ability to think?

Last spring, it became clear to me that over half the students in my large general education lecture course had used artificial intelligence tools, contrary to my explicit policy, to write their final take-home exams. (Ironically, the course was titled Contemporary Moral Problems: The Value of Human Life.) I had asked them about some very recent work in philosophy, parts of which happened to share titles with entirely different ideas in medieval theology. You can guess which topics the students ended up "writing" about.

My situation was hardly unique — rampant A.I. cheating has been reported all over the country. But I felt a dread I struggled to express until a colleague articulated the problem in stark terms: "Our students are about to turn subcognitive," she said. That was it. At stake are not just specialized academic skills or refined habits of mind, but also the most basic form of cognitive fluency. To leave our students to their own devices — which is to say, to the devices of A.I. companies — is to deprive them of indispensable opportunities to develop their linguistic mastery, and with it their most elementary powers of thought. This means they will lack the means to understand the world they live in or navigate it effectively.

A.I. is hardly the first technology to threaten our cognitive competence. Long before ChatGPT, the smartphone and the calculator, Plato warned against writing itself. Literate human beings, he foresaw, would "not use their memories." He was not entirely wrong. But few of us would consider this a bad bargain. The written word is, after all, the condition for the survival of these very same Platonic dialogues across two millenniums. Great gifts have often come at great cost. The question is always: Are they worth it?

As students' A.I. use has proliferated, many of its critics focused on intellectual gifts. "A.I. undermines the human value of attention," the poet Meghan O'Rourke wrote in a guest essay for Times Opinion, "and the individuality that flows from that." Other endangered powers: "unique human expression," "the slow deliberation of critical thinking" and the "ability to write original and interesting sentences." As a humanities professor, all these concerns resonate with me...

Anastasia Berg
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/29/opinion/ai-students-thinking-school-reading.html?unlocked_article_code=1.xE8.cbCE.xWI9KNbZ3YzQ&smid=em-share

"Have you tried taking long walks?"

Which Is Better, One Long Walk or Many Short Ones?

A new analysis is one of the first to study whether spacing steps out or consolidating them was linked to better health outcomes.

"...Those who regularly walked longer than 15 minutes were 80 percent less likely to die from any cause and nearly 70 percent less likely to develop cardiovascular disease over a roughly 10-year period, compared with those who got most of their steps in walks of five minutes or less..."

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/27/well/move/long-short-walks-health.html?smid=em-share


Crash and recovery

The stock market crash of 10.29.29, the ensuing economic depression, the New Deal—and then ๐ŸŽถHappy days were here again…

HCR
https://open.substack.com/pub/heathercoxrichardson/p/october-28-2025?r=35ogp&utm_medium=ios

Try this

"At the end of my show in Princeton, NJ last Friday, I took questions from the audience. The final question was from a Princeton undergraduate, who asked how to deal with the stress she and her fellow students are feeling in our current dystopia.

I shared some advice that my grandfather gave me..."

Andy Borowitz
https://open.substack.com/pub/borowitzreport/p/secret-to-happiness?r=35ogp&utm_medium=ios

Amazing

"Happiness is amazing. It's so amazing, it doesn't matter whether it's yours or not. It's that lovely thing; a society grows great when old men plant trees, the shade of which they know they will never sit in. Good people do things for other people. That's it, the end." -Anne in 'After Life'.
 


Reminds me of...

“An individual human existence should be like a river - small at first, narrowly contained within it's banks, and rushing passionately past rocks and waterfalls. Gradually, the river grows wider, the banks recede, the waters flow more quietly, and in the end, without any visible break, they become merged with the sea, and painlessly lose their individual being.” Bertrand Russell, How to Grow Old

And



  •  
  •   



Tuesday, October 28, 2025

Questions Oct 30

Pizza Party/Open House 'til 6:30 in JUB 202, an opportunity to learn about Spring PHIL/RS courses. We'll see if we can end class a little early so we can get over there before all the pizza and profs get gone.



Concluding Against Happiness... If you've not yet indicated a final report presentation date/topic, please do so. Or I can assign one.

  1. What's the problem with "subjectivist" happiness? 207 What is the appropriate role for subjectivity to play in our respective happiness pursuits, do you think?
  2. Happiness in the deep sense necessarily involves what? 210 What does this mean to you?
  3. "How satisfied are you with your life" fails to capture the Japanese emphasis on ___ and ___. 219
  4. When happiness is assessed in less ___ ways, students in the U.S. and Japan do not differ. 224
  5. Jeffrey Sachs defends a moderate happiness agenda that interprets happiness as what? 228
  6. What would Aristotle predict about the link between happiness and a virtuous character? 232
  7. To what sorts of behaviors are people's different ideals related? 238
  8. What is "ipsatizing" and why should it be used? 245

Artful Dodgers

FREDDIE FREEMAN WALK-OFF HOME RUN IN THE 18TH INNING!

 https://www.threads.com/@mlb/post/DQV_BqYiXYl?xmt=AQF0yTg1XtZqxBb591r1V6kVh1GYQRFNVG2LkwsdJQPVKQ&slof=1

e

Monday, October 27, 2025

“GenZ is worse than you think”

Is it?

"…Figures like Charlie Kirk and Ben Shapiro often advise young people to become Christian, get married, and have kids young. Many, including myself, object to such a narrow vision of happiness, but they aren't wrong about having connection, moral framework, and responsibilities, as footholds in life. Too many of Gen Z have fallen into a life with little connection or responsibility to the outside world because it's no longer a basic requirement to survive. And by responsibility, I don't mean feeling pressure to solve the big issues like climate change, I mean a life of small responsibilities, of things that will not save the world. Driving our friends to the airport instead of letting them Uber. Helping a neighbor carry groceries. Showing up to a nephew's sports practice. Starting a garden to tend to. Little by little we can find structures for our freedom that enable our joy and build a life of them."

Clare Ashcraft writes The Mestiza where she makes observations about identity, psychology, and culture. She is a proud Ohioan.

https://open.substack.com/pub/therepublicofletters/p/gen-z-is-worse-than-you-think?r=35ogp&utm_medium=ios

Happily educated


"Recently, I talked about how to make higher education happy again with a wonderful panel at the Harvard Kennedy School. The topics ranged beyond the cost of college, and also addressed more serious problems with universities. Despite all of higher education’s problems, I still believe in its promise: The university is my home, after all." Arthur Brooks

GrAttitude

Your brain takes in about 11 million bits of information per second, but you can consciously process only about 40.

That means you're not seeing the full picture. Your attention decides what makes the cut.

Practicing gratitude trains your selective attention system to notice more of what's positive, meaningful, and supportive around you.

It's not that life suddenly gets better.
It's that you start noticing the parts that already are.

—GM

Plan

Steer clear of the cliff's edge

"What's the point of living longer if you're unhappy?"
 


The view from 85
Roger did not fall off Peter Attia's "cliff" at 75.
"…In my younger years I was always looking ahead for whatever would befall me. Now I look at what I have. And as those in their 80s appreciate, what one has is considerable. I don't fear winter, and I don't regret spring..." nyt

Sunday, October 26, 2025

Stop being “productive”

Be human.

"Productivity is a trap. Becoming more efficient just makes you more rushed and trying to clear the decks simply makes them fill up again… Since finitude defines our lives…living a truly authentic life—becoming fully human—means facing up to that fact."

https://www.themarginalian.org/2021/12/20/four-thousand-weeks-oliver-burkeman/

Friday, October 24, 2025

Fwd: presentation!!!

Heres my [May's] slide presentation. It has to be opened on google slides because it has animations on it!!

Questions Oct 28

 

  1. Interpretive challenges to a reliable picture of happiness are especially pronounced in which societies? 149
  2. What did the American Psychiatric Association apologize for in 2021? 154
  3. What kinds of questions do the authors think should be added to subjective well-being studies? 160
  4. Measures of "hedonic balance" typically focus on what? How might this be misleading? 164
  5. Judgments of life satisfaction are arbitrary in part because there's no reason to think most people know where to set what? 173
  6. What's the difference between being judiciously positive and being Pollyanna? 180-81
  7. Work in philosophy of language and logic, linguistics, and the emotions definitively shows what? 186
  8. The consensus seems to be that the primary duties of a good society are  what? Do they unambiguously predict happiness? 189
  9. The authors have contended that what goods come first? 191
  10. Instead of, or in addition to, a worldwide movement to advance happiness the authors propose that educators do what? 201-2

Awe

Sometimes the smallest moments of wonder can have the biggest impact on our mental health.

A new study found that people living with long COVID who practiced brief "awe" exercises—like pausing to notice beauty, kindness, or vastness—experienced less depression and stress, and greater well-being after just four weeks.

For me, awe often comes from looking up at the night sky and marveling at how big the universe is.

What gives you a sense of awe? Share in the comments!

Laurie Santos
https://www.threads.com/@lauriesantosofficial/post/DQJyOotjC8x?xmt=AQF0qpKLG-6jQQc5eGmuFlK5ie_SyL93CNlGv5KApDl6wQ&slof=1

Thursday, October 23, 2025

Arthur Brooks‘s happy morning routine: mostly good (but forget #4!)

  1. 1. Wake up before dawn: Research shows that getting up before the sun rises can improve your creativity, focus and memory, he said. Brooks wakes up at 4:30 a.m. nearly every day, and has experienced positive effects on his mental health as a result.
  2. 2. Engage in physical activity: "Fifteen minutes after I wake up, I'm in the gym," said Brooks who has a gym in his home. He exercises for an hour a day, seven days a week, and alternates between cardio and resistance training.
  3. 3. Get metaphysical: Taking a page out of the Dalai Lama's book, Brooks practices his version of analytical meditation each morning, by attending Mass or praying a Catholic meditation in his car, "calibrating the work of the soul," he said. If you aren't religious or into meditation, you can gain similar benefits from journaling for 20 to 30 minutes, Brooks added.
  4. 4. Delay coffee intake: "I love coffee for sure, but I don't drink it when I first wake up," he said. "As a matter of fact, I don't have my first cup of coffee until 7:30 in the morning." He finds that it prevents him from having a 3 p.m. slump later in the day.
  5. 5. Eat a high-protein breakfast: Brooks eats between 175 and 200 grams of protein each day, so he gets about 60 grams of protein for breakfast by eating unflavored, non-fat Greek yogurt with whey protein, walnuts and berries. "It makes me feel great. It keeps me full all through the morning and fueled up," he said.
  6. 6. Enter a flow state: Instead of using the energy that his morning routine gives him to check emails, take phone calls or read the paper, Brooks starts working right away. "When I do that, I can actually get two hours of super high-quality creative work," he said. "I'm in the flow for the rest of the day."

https://www.threads.com/@cnbc/post/DQIRSYwEpim?xmt=AQF0QOvw-pNhtOZDZ3OBpcN1zUA-ZZJMoDaYjdJxBP4bOA&slof=1

Wednesday, October 22, 2025

True cosmopolitans, living gracefully and at home in the cosmic forest

I mentioned Jennifer Michael Hecht's discussion of the Epicurean notion that we can either consider ourselves lost in the forest (or the cosmos), as it were, OR we can "hang a sign on a tree that says HOME" and resolve to make ourselves at home... wherever we find ourselves in the "vast and sprawling" universe. That would make us true cosmopolitans, citizens of the cosmos or (as Diogenes the Cynic said) the world.


Hecht:

"Where the Hellenistic philosophies excelled was the production of what could be called secular religions. They were based on self-help–oriented doctrines often borrowed from the earlier philosophers but interpreted and presented in a way that made more direct sense to a lot of people. I'm calling them graceful-life philosophies to distinguish them from other philosophy. Their goals were practical happiness, and they were not merely theoretical about it: they provided community, mediations, and events. In this they were more like religions, but they did not identify themselves as religions and they had remarkably little use for God or gods

The Hellenistic graceful-life philosophies had a lot in common. The experience of doubt in a heterogeneous, cosmopolitan world is a bit like being lost in a forest, unendingly beckoned by a thousand possible routes. At every juncture, with every step, one is confronted with alternative paths, so that the second-guessing becomes more infuriating even than the fact of being lost. After a direction is chosen, one is constantly met with another tree in one's path. What do you do if you come from a culture that had a powerful sense of home and local value, and now you are lost in something vast and sprawling, meaningless and strange? The stronger your belief in that half-remembered home, the more likely you are to panic, to grow claustrophobic among the trees and beneath their skyless canopy. Hellenistic men and women felt a desperate desire to get out of the seemingly endless, friendless woods. 

The graceful-life philosophies of this period were able to achieve an amazing rescue mission for the human being lost in the woods and bone-tired of searching for home. They did this by noticing that we could stop being lost if we were to just stop trying to get out of the forest. Instead, we could pick some blueberries, sit beneath a tree, and start describing how the sun-dappled forest floor shimmers in the breeze. The initial horror of being lost utterly disappears when you come to believe fully that there is no town out there, beyond the forest, to which you are headed. If there is no release, no going home, then this must be home, this shimmering instant replete with blueberries. Hang a sign that says HOME on a tree and you're done; just try to have a good time. Thus the cosmopolitan doubter looks back on earlier generations with bemused sympathy—they were mistaken—and looks upon believing contemporaries with real pity, as creatures scurrying through the forest, idiotically searching for a way out of the human condition. After all, it isn't so bad if you just settle in and accept a few difficult ideas from the get-go."

— Doubt: A History: The Great Doubters and Their Legacy of Innovation from Socrates and Jesus to Thomas Jefferson and Emily Dickinson by Jennifer M. Hecht



Fwd: Presentation



---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Nicholas Bagwell <nwb2w@mtmail.mtsu.edu>
Date: Tue, Oct 21, 2025 at 5:15 PM
Subject: Presentation
To: Phil Oliver <Phil.Oliver@mtsu.edu>


Me too, Laurie

Laurie Santos:
"I've been reflecting on gratitude lately, and today I'm especially grateful for the Yale undergrads I'm working with this semester.

Their curiosity and energy remind me why I love teaching. They push me to be better every day, and I'm so lucky to learn alongside them.

As I work on building my own gratitude practice (it's a process!), I'm reminded that taking a moment to appreciate the people around us can make all the difference."

Simone de Beauvoir on the art of growing older

How to keep life from becoming a parody of itself –

https://www.themarginalian.org/2022/07/31/simone-de-beauvoir-coming-of-age/

Against doom-scrolling

Good advice from a pedaling & early-rising Brit: "…moving forward is what makes me happy"-

https://www.threads.com/@johnoverity/post/DQFDY1GE7zo?xmt=AQF00uC1kMs0mKXTHn5HEtGsRERAJGscXBjT4iqnItMTBg&slof=1

intentional presence

(A reflective species must work at being present… unlike ๐Ÿ•๐Ÿ•‍๐Ÿฆบ)

Do you ever feel like time is moving faster?

Here's why.

When we're young, everything is new. The brain records each moment in rich detail, creating more "memory markers," which make time feel full.

As we get older, the brain gets efficient. It groups repeated experiences together—less novelty, fewer memories, and time seems to collapse.

The antidote?

Each act of intentional presence slows life down again.

—gratitude mind

Tuesday, October 21, 2025

Questions OCT 23

  1. The authors say proponents of the happiness agenda "only want to know" what? 97
  2. What kind of property, implied by the averaging and ranking of happiness scores, do the authors insist does not exist? 100-101
  3. By which metrics are Finland, The Netherlands, and Vietnam (respectively) the world's happiest countries? 103-4
  4. With what sorts of outcomes are positive and negative emotions correlated? 107 How do Anglophone and East Asian cultures differ on them? 114
  5. What did J.S. Mill say about people who are inappropriately happy? Do you agree? 110-11
  6. Who said "much laughter deadens the heart." Agree? 112-3
  7. What groups do the authors offer as examples of people who are happy "for the wrong reasons"? 117
  8. The cultural fit of emotions contributes to subjective well-being and to what? 122
  9. What did Edward Slingerland say about the Chinese concept of Tian? 138
  10. Chinese feminism is mostly about what? 145

Monday, October 20, 2025

Position Vacant: a Leader

However heartening the massive No Kings demonstrations last weekend, the problem is that there is no leadership and no stated programme for opposition to Trump. The United States is in danger, severe danger, and this rudderlessness is fatal. The wish that a handful of Republicans would stand up against Trump in Congress – which is all that it would take; but the staggering degree of cowardice infecting the GoP makes this currently a no-hoper – means that the will of the millions who took to the streets has to aggregate into a voice and a definite agenda for protecting the state and halting its precipitous slide into ugly authoritarian dictatorship.

Trump is out of control; neither reason nor decency, neither a sense of constitutional principle nor care for the American people, matters to him. His aggressive and brutal exercise of power, allowed by an utterly supine Congress and a lickspittle Supreme Court, has given him as much opportunity to do what he wants as any absolute monarch in history.

In the ideal, a constitution should be so ordered that no individual or clique can do what Trump is doing. But the US constitution has failed its people at last, so what its founders hoped it would do – prevent rule by a power-mad greedy unprincipled man – has left the US at Trump's feet. Even George III in the tea-party days did not have as much power as Trump is wielding – know your history, and compare; you will be shocked...

A.C. Grayling, continues

Facing facts, living well, grieving aptly, being happy

A mantra for the philosophy of self-help: feeling happy is not the same as living well. Philosophers make the case with “experience machines” that offer streams of blissful, meaningless illusion; but this is extravagant and metaphysically contested. Better to cite the mundane reality that, other things equal, we should feel bad when we hear bad news. This is what it means to face the facts, as we do when we grieve the lost; and it is part of living well...

Kieran Setiya (continues)

Friday, October 17, 2025

Jayden's "Against Happiness" presentation

https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1TMjcYE73j5EeeEHuxJKKEEwQ9yQw9Qj1i7TC1kQpOMk/edit

Questions OCT 21

  1. What alternative "businesses" might be appropriate to governments? Does this really have to be an exclusive disjunction? 43-4
  2. What do "philosophers call 'content'"? 50 What does this suggest to you about the relation between evidence and experience?
  3. It seems obvious that "it is one thing to be happy, another to be good" (51) but in Pragmatism William James asks if we can "keep the notion of what is better for us, and what is true for us, permanently apart?" * COMMENT?
  4. "True happiness...might not involve feeling happy at all." 57 Which famous happiness author is referenced in connection with this claim? Do you think he'd entirely agree? At all seems excessive, doesn't it?
  5. Why do you think 40% of American teens suffer "persistent sadness and hopelessness"? What would you advise they do?
  6. What's special about age forty? 63
  7. Do we need a Ministry of Happiness? 73 (Or perhaps for the Future?)
  8. How does English differ from other languages in the relation of happy to happiness? 86
  9. What sort of happiness "involves no smiling or laughing"? 90 Do serenity and contentment not make you ever smile or laugh?
  10. About what is Haybron 100% clear? 94

*...truth is ONE SPECIES OF GOOD, and not, as is usually supposed, a category distinct from good, and co-ordinate with it. THE TRUE IS THE NAME OF WHATEVER PROVES ITSELF TO BE GOOD IN THE WAY OF BELIEF, AND GOOD, TOO, FOR DEFINITE, ASSIGNABLE REASONS. Surely you must admit this, that if there were NO good for life in true ideas, or if the knowledge of them were positively disadvantageous and false ideas the only useful ones, then the current notion that truth is divine and precious, and its pursuit a duty, could never have grown up or become a dogma. In a world like that, our duty would be to SHUN truth, rather. But in this world, just as certain foods are not only agreeable to our taste, but good for our teeth, our stomach and our tissues; so certain ideas are not only agreeable to think about, or agreeable as supporting other ideas that we are fond of, but they are also helpful in life's practical struggles. If there be any life that it is really better we should lead, and if there be any idea which, if believed in, would help us to lead that life, then it would be really BETTER FOR US to believe in that idea, UNLESS, INDEED, BELIEF IN IT INCIDENTALLY CLASHED WITH OTHER GREATER VITAL BENEFITS.

'What would be better for us to believe'! This sounds very like a definition of truth. It comes very near to saying 'what we OUGHT to believe': and in THAT definition none of you would find any oddity. Ought we ever not to believe what it is BETTER FOR US to believe? And can we then keep the notion of what is better for us, and what is true for us, permanently apart?And this, also from Pragmatism, is relevant to our discussion last time about different levels of discourse that shouldn't be "reduced" or "eliminated":

Common sense is BETTER for one sphere of life, science for another, philosophic criticism for a third; but whether either be TRUER absolutely, Heaven only knows. Just now, if I understand the matter rightly, we are witnessing a curious reversion to the common-sense way of looking at physical nature, in the philosophy of science favored by such men as Mach, Ostwald and Duhem. According to these teachers no hypothesis is truer than any other in the sense of being a more literal copy of reality. They are all but ways of talking on our part, to be compared solely from the point of view of their USE. The only literally true thing is REALITY; and the only reality we know is, for these logicians, sensible reality, the flux of our sensations and emotions as they pass.
==

Looking Backward: 2000-1887 by Edward Bellamy

As mentioned in class…
"Edward Bellamy's 1888 classic look at the future has been translated into over twenty languages and is the most widely read novel of its time. A young Boston gentleman is mysteriously transported from the nineteenth to the twenty-first century -- from a world of war and want to one of peace and plenty. This brilliant vision became the blueprint of utopia that stimulated some of the greatest thinkers of our age."  https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/296977.Looking_Backward


An excerpt:

""To borrow a phrase which was often used in your day, we should not consider life worth living if we had to be surrounded by a population of ignorant, boorish, coarse, wholly uncultivated men and women, as was the plight of the few educated in your day. Is a man satisfied, merely because he is perfumed himself, to mingle with a malodorous crowd? Could he take more than a very limited satisfaction, even in a palatial apartment, if the windows on all four sides opened into stable yards? And yet just that was the situation of those considered most fortunate as to culture and refinement in your day. I know that the poor and ignorant envied the rich and cultured then; but to us the latter, living as they did, surrounded by squalor and brutishness, seem little better off than the former. The cultured man in your age was like one up to the neck in a nauseous bog solacing himself with a smelling bottle. You see, perhaps, now, how we look at this question of universal high education. No single thing is so important to every man as to have for neighbors intelligent, companionable persons. There is nothing, therefore, which the nation can do for him that will enhance so much his own happiness as to educate his neighbors. When it fails to do so, the value of his own education to him is reduced by half, and many of the tastes he has cultivated are made positive sources of pain.

"To educate some to the highest degree, and leave the mass wholly uncultivated, as you did, made the gap between them almost like that between different natural species, which have no means of communication. What could be more inhuman than this consequence of a partial enjoyment of education! Its universal and equal enjoyment leaves, indeed, the differences between men as to natural endowments as marked as in a state of nature, but the level of the lowest is vastly raised. Brutishness is eliminated. All have some inkling of the humanities, some appreciation of the things of the mind, and an admiration for the still higher culture they have fallen short of. They have become capable of receiving and imparting, in various degrees, but all in some measure, the pleasures and inspirations of a refined social life. The cultured society of the nineteenth century—what did it consist of but here and there a few microscopic oases in a vast, unbroken wilderness? The proportion of individuals capable of intellectual sympathies or refined intercourse, to the mass of their contemporaries, used to be so infinitesimal as to be in any broad view of humanity scarcely worth mentioning. One generation of the world to-day represents a greater volume of intellectual life than any five centuries ever did before.

"There is still another point I should mention in stating the grounds on which nothing less than the universality of the best education could now be tolerated," continued Dr. Leete, "and that is, the interest of the coming generation in having educated parents. To put the matter in a nutshell, there are three main grounds on which our educational system rests: first, the right of every man to the completest education the nation can give him on his own account, as necessary to his enjoyment of himself; second, the right of his fellow-citizens to have him educated, as necessary to their enjoyment of his society; third, the right of the unborn to be guaranteed an intelligent and refined parentage.""

  • “There is no such thing in a civilized society as self-support. In a state of society so barbarous as not even to know family cooperation, each individual may possibly support himself, though even then for a part of his life only; but from the moment that men begin to live together, and constitute even the rudest of society, self-support becomes impossible. As men grow more civilized, and the subdivision of occupations and services is carried out, a complex mutual dependence becomes the universal rule. Every man, however solitary may seem his occupation, is a member of a vast industrial partnership, as large as the nation, as large as humanity. The necessity of mutual dependence should imply the duty and guarantee of mutual support...”
  • “They were not serving the public interest, but their immediate personal interest, and it was nothing to them what the ultimate effect of their course on the general prosperity might be, if but they increased their own hoard, for these goods were their own, and the more they sold and the more they got for them, the greater their gain. The more wasteful the people were, the more articles they did not want which they could be induced to buy, the better for these sellers.”
  • “Moreover, the excessive individualism which then prevailed was inconsistent with much public spirit. What little wealth you had seems almost wholly to have been lavished in private luxury. Nowadays, on the contrary, there is no destination of the surplus wealth so popular as the adornment of the city, which all enjoy in equal degree.”
— Looking Backward: 2000-1887 (Illustrated) by Edward Bellamy

==
AND, there's a British version from 1890...


  • News from Nowhere (1890) is the best-known prose work of William Morris and the only significant English utopia to be written since Thomas More's. The novel describes the encounter between a visitor from the nineteenth century, William Guest, and a decentralized and humane socialist future. Set over a century after a revolutionary upheaval in 1952, these "Chapters from a Utopian Romance" recount his journey across London and up the Thames to Kelmscott Manor, Morris's own country house in Oxfordshire. Drawing on the work of John Ruskin and Karl Marx, Morris's book is not only an evocative statement of his egalitarian convictions but also a distinctive contribution to the utopian tradition. Morris's rejection of state socialism and his ambition to transform the relationship between humankind and the natural world, give News from Nowhere a particular resonance for modern readers. This text is based on the 1891 version, incorporating the extensive revisions made by Morris to the first edition.
  • "If others can see it as I have seen it, then it may be called a vision rather than a dream".
  • "It is real learning, knowledge cultivated for its own sake—the Art of Knowledge, in short—which is followed there, not the Commercial learning of the past".
  • "We are only the trustees for those who come after us".
  • "Have nothing in your house you do not know to be useful or believe to be beautiful. Nothing useless can be truly beautiful".
  • "The true secret of happiness lies in taking a genuine interest in all the details of daily life".
 https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/189746.News_from_Nowhere

 


Believing in "the continuous life of the world"

     "...and consequently we are happy."

"More akin to our way of looking at life was the spirit of the Middle Ages, to whom heaven and the life of the next world was such a reality, that it became to them a part of the life upon the earth; which accordingly they loved and adorned, in spite of the ascetic doctrines of their formal creed, which bade them contemn it.

But that also, with its assured belief in heaven and hell as two countries in which to live, has gone, and now we do, both in word and in deed, believe in the continuous life of the world of men, and as it were, add every day of that common life to the little stock of days which our own mere individual experience wins for us: and consequently we are happy."

News from Nowhere by William Morris

==
The conclusion of "News from Nowhere"—

"I lay in my bed in my house at dingy Hammersmith thinking about it all; and trying to consider if I was overwhelmed with despair at finding I had been dreaming a dream; and strange to say, I found that I was not so despairing.

Or indeed WAS it a dream? If so, why was I so conscious all along that I was really seeing all that new life from the outside, still wrapped up in the prejudices, the anxieties, the distrust of this time of doubt and struggle?

All along, though those friends were so real to me, I had been feeling as if I had no business amongst them: as though the time would come when they would reject me, and say, as Ellen's last mournful look seemed to say, "No, it will not do; you cannot be of us; you belong so entirely to the unhappiness of the past that our happiness even would weary you. Go back again, now you have seen us, and your outward eyes have learned that in spite of all the infallible maxims of your day there is yet a time of rest in store for the world, when mastery has changed into fellowship—but not before. Go back again, then, and while you live you will see all round you people engaged in making others live lives which are not their own, while they themselves care nothing for their own real lives—men who hate life though they fear death. Go back and be the happier for having seen us, for having added a little hope to your struggle. Go on living while you may, striving, with whatsoever pain and labour needs must be, to build up little by little the new day of fellowship, and rest, and happiness."

Yes, surely! and if others can see it as I have seen it, then it may be called a vision rather than a dream."

— News from Nowhere(Annotated & illustrated) by William Morris
https://a.co/0MkT3QW

Edward Bellamy would not be happy about this


Moral holidays

Following up our discussion of "moral holidays" as a way of reconciling the pursuit of happiness with the perennial fight against injustice and pursuit of meaning and purpose etc.--
...[For those who believe in a divine providence, or a rationalistic/Hegelian Absolute] we have a right ever and anon to take a moral holiday, to let the world wag in its own way, feeling that its issues are in better hands than ours and are none of our business.

The universe is a system of which the individual members may relax their anxieties occasionally, in which the don't-care mood is also right for men, and moral holidays in order—that, if I mistake not, is part, at least, of what the Absolute is 'known-as,' that is the great difference in our particular experiences which his being true makes for us, that is part of his cash-value when he is pragmatically interpreted. Farther than that the ordinary lay-reader in philosophy who thinks favorably of absolute idealism does not venture to sharpen his conceptions. He can use the Absolute for so much, and so much is very precious. He is pained at hearing you speak incredulously of the Absolute, therefore, and disregards your criticisms because they deal with aspects of the conception that he fails to follow...

I said just now that what is better for us to believe is true UNLESS THE BELIEF INCIDENTALLY CLASHES WITH SOME OTHER VITAL BENEFIT. Now in real life what vital benefits is any particular belief of ours most liable to clash with? What indeed except the vital benefits yielded by OTHER BELIEFS when these prove incompatible with the first ones? In other words, the greatest enemy of any one of our truths may be the rest of our truths. Truths have once for all this desperate instinct of self-preservation and of desire to extinguish whatever contradicts them. My belief in the Absolute, based on the good it does me, must run the gauntlet of all my other beliefs. Grant that it may be true in giving me a moral holiday. Nevertheless, as I conceive it,—and let me speak now confidentially, as it were, and merely in my own private person,—it clashes with other truths of mine whose benefits I hate to give up on its account. It happens to be associated with a kind of logic of which I am the enemy, I find that it entangles me in metaphysical paradoxes that are inacceptable, etc., etc.. But as I have enough trouble in life already without adding the trouble of carrying these intellectual inconsistencies, I personally just give up the Absolute. I just TAKE my moral holidays; or else as a professional philosopher, I try to justify them by some other principle. --William James, Pragmatism II
==  ==
...let me explain why 'moral holidays' were the only gift of the absolute which I picked out for emphasis. I was primarily concerned in my lectures with contrasting the belief that the world is still in process of making with the belief that there is an 'eternal' edition of it ready-made and complete. The former, or 'pluralistic' belief, was the one that my pragmatism favored...

...If, as pluralists, we grant ourselves moral holidays, they can only be provisional breathing-spells, intended to refresh us for the morrow's fight...

...The pragmatism or pluralism which I defend has to fall back on a certain ultimate hardihood, a certain willingness to live without assurances or guarantees. To minds thus willing to live on possibilities that are not certainties, quietistic religion, sure of salvation any how, has a slight flavor of fatty degeneration about it which has caused it to be looked askance on, even in the church... --William James, The Meaning of Truth 11

==

John Lachs at Harvard, 2014--

Saints everywhere

Perspective-changing books

Henry Oliver asked Substack: what is the one book that changed your perspective on life the most? After HUNDREDS of responses, these were th...